Audacity, Courage, and the Unity of Virtue
When I was assistant professor, I was in full possession of the three qualities that characterize young scholars – educational loans, modest pay, and summers off. As the second quality was barely sufficient to meet the demands of the first, I used the third to supplement my income. In practice, this meant that I was leading organizational development activities, such as team-building exercises and action planning workshops. After a time, these sessions became somewhat routine, and I began to notice commonalities in people’s comments. Among each group’s developmental needs was something to the effect of “people around here need to take more risks.” Usually, it was one of the first items on every list, typically articulated right after “we need better communication” but just before “we need to show each other more respect.”
I am not certain how many times I heard those words (“people around here need to take more risks,” “people around here need to take more risks,” “people around here” … you get the point) before something dawned on me. Those plucky individuals were all advocating the same thing in the same way. Far from being courageous, this is a sign that people are repeating something that is socially desirable but without thinking about what it means. Risk-taking behavior, when considered in isolation, cannot be virtuous behavior. It cannot even be good business. The problem is a straightforward matter of definitions. When we speak of “bravery,” we are not talking about only one thing, for there are at least two. I will loosely call them audacity and courage, and they are not exactly the same. Unless the listener knows precisely which is intended, then the advice is worse than pointless, for it may lead to error.
To illustrate these two qualities, we should consider the distinction made by the ancient Greeks between audacity/boldness (thrasytes), on the one hand, and courage (andreia), on the other. These two types of bravery were illustrated in one of my favorite historical novels, Tides of War, by Steven Pressfield. Tides of War recounts the life of Polemidas, a fictional Athenian solider, who was a friend to the very real Alcibiades during the Peloponnesian War. (Spoiler alert: Athens loses the war.)
Late in the novel, the Spartan general, Lysander, is preparing his forces for the final assault on Athens. His men wonder why he had delayed, rather than devastating the crippled Athenians forthwith. In response to these reproaches, Lysander defends himself in a speech to his men. In the course of this oratory, he defines thrasytes and andreia, doing so in a way that leaves no doubt as to which of these attributes will win the Peloponnesian War. I will quote directly, but ask the reader to forgive the sexist language. These fictional events took place about 2500 years ago.
“The bold man [thrasytes] is prideful, brazen, ambitious. The brave man [andreia] is calm, God-fearing, steady. The bold man seeks to divide; he wants his own and will shoulder his brother aside to loot it. The brave man unites. He succors his fellow, knowing that what belongs to the commonwealth belongs to him as well. The bold man covets; he sues his neighbor in the law court, he intrigues, he dissembles. The brave man is content with his lot; he respects that portion the gods have granted and husbands it, comporting himself with humility as heaven’s steward …”
“[Courage] is the issue of selflessness, brotherhood, and love of freedom. Boldness, on the other hand, is spawned of defiance and disrespect; it is the bastard brat of irreverence and outlawry. Boldness honors two things only: novelty and success. It feeds on them and without them dies.”
This is why all this talk of “risk-taking” confused me. I was not certain, and I don’t believe that the speakers were either, of whether they were talking about thrasytes or andreia. Indeed, I suspect that many people do not fully appreciate the difference between, to use my English translations, audacity and courage.
Let me start by articulating what this distinction is not. The issue here is not a matter of degree. That is, I do not see audacity as courage that has been taken too far. To be sure, everyone would acknowledge that businesspeople (and others) sometimes take ill-advised risks, but this is not what distinguishes thrasytes from andreia. Rather, I would argue that andreia, courage, possesses something that thrasytes, audacity, lacks. This secret ingredient is why courage is a virtue and audacity/boldness is not. This ingredient also explains why it is generally a good idea to recommend risk-taking that is courageous, but not generally a good idea to recommend risk-taking that is audacious.
Let us return to Tides of War. For Steven Pressfield, thrasytes (what we have translated as audacity or boldness) asserts the self. It tends to elevate the individual with personal achievements and/or glory. It can be competitive, as the individual tries to overcome obstacles. As such, the bold person may be discourteous, even shunting others aside while seeking private gain. For this reason, audacity threatens to become divisive. It is further significant that thrasytes involves no higher principle, unless one counts the pursuit of personal advantage. Andreia (what we have translated as courage) is a different phenomenon. It subordinates the self to a worthy mission or cause, often by working with others. Andreia is collective. It respects the community and its needs. This is why courage is group-oriented, uniting people together, and also principled, as one is subordinated to a higher purpose. While both thrasytes and andreia are characterized by a willingness to take risks, the latter also includes some additional elements – a readiness to place oneself at the service of an important cause, a sincere interest in the well-being of others, a willingness to forgo personal gain, and some higher principle.
We can understand this more fully if we consider Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics. Aristotle’s basic argument was that for any virtue to be fully expressed, a person needs to possess the others. In the present case, risk-taking becomes a virtue when it is supplemented by additional worthwhile qualities, such as loyalty, generosity (selflessness), justice, and love. When these are lacking, and when risk-taking is simply an individual pursuing personal success, then – by definition – it is not courage but audacity. And, lacking the reinforcing virtues, audacity cannot itself be a virtue. In other words, virtue (the singular) is a kind of unity. One virtue depends in large measure on the others, and when the others are absent then the putative virtue is transformed into something else.
After many years, I think I understand what went wrong at those organizational development sessions. To say, “people around here need to take more risks” fails to appreciate the unity of virtue. Without this key idea, we begin to act as if a courageous person and an audacious person are the same thing. In other words, we fail to distinguish between thrasytes, which asserts the self, and andreia, which subordinates the self to a worthwhile cause. We treat both types of risk-taking as if they were equally worthy of merit, thereby misapplying our admiration and our censure. For that reason, people sometimes admire certain self-serving actions, which are simply bold and ultimately self-serving, while disregarding other actions, which are courageous and protect communities. We have lost the key to telling the two apart.
I will close with a suggestion. They next time you are participating in an organizational development session, you might wish to recommend the following — “People around here need to be more courageous.” But if you are uncomfortable with that, here is something else for you to consider – “People around here need to be less audacious.”
inspiring
Hookup With Local Girls Looking For Sex: http://v.ht/4eLbaW?1Mq8afPh
Popular tags: dating websites for older singles, totally jewish dating, dawson street dating agency, indian dating in india, dating website for metalheads, yoseob iu dating, best dating sites california, speed dating kate nowak, questionnaire dating my daughter, no credit dating site, free dating sites for smokers, online dating girl fat, list the types of radiometric dating, speed dating meme maker, free south african dating apps, britney spears the hook up traduГ§ГЈo, south africa free online dating site, browning shotguns dating, free online dating sites portugal, dating profile examples in spanish, totally free indian dating site, fb hookup list, text dating sites australia, muslim dating scorpion, flt dating site, dating in ottawa ontario, metro pcs hook up phone, dating 3 years and no proposal, dating nails and screws, dating hits, best dating sites australia 2016, science dating puns, wot matchmaking rigged, 35 dating 21, interracial dating indianapolis, waterloo dating site, kamloops dating service, non sign up dating sites, speed dating bathurst, dating warner robins ga, speed dating krakow, marriage not dating ep 5 eng, dating sites mobile apps, speed dating sydney north shore, speed dating nights, watch dating agency cyrano ep 2, maxwell dating 2013, japanese dating sims for iphone, pisces and capricorn dating, divorced mom dating younger man, cobra cb radio hook up, hook up off tinder, what is the legal age difference for dating in north carolina, free mexican dating websites, how long after separation start dating, steam matchmaking, christian dating sites in nairobi, tips for dating website profiles, 100 completely free uk dating sites, cool dating apps, macon speed dating, dating profile examples looking for, electron spin resonance dating of south australian megafauna sites, titanfall matchmaking 2015, full hookup camping california, speed dating komedia, ph 7 social dating cms, why online dating is bad essay, what’s the point of dating in college, best gay dating apps canada, indonesia free dating website, how do you tell your parents you’re dating an older man, prezi online dating, is carol and daryl dating, dating search module jomsocial, how fast to move with online dating, boyfriend still on online dating sites, 30 year old woman dating 60 year old man, speed dating westlake village ca, manchester dating scene, central new jersey speed dating, des moines social club speed dating, estonia dating agency, inmate online dating, british dating agency, 40 year old virgin speed dating breast scene, free online goth dating sites, matchmaking awards, destiny matchmaking strike missions, serial daters on online dating, birmingham dating sites, dating online qatar, faithful dating sites, matchmaking vacations, dating a very handsome man, online dating good morning america, double your dating audiobook download, my ex is dating a fat ugly girl, radiometric dating of rocks, ihk speed dating aachen 2014, best dating apps usa, rules for online dating ellen fein, dating szene de erfahrung, good words for dating profile, what’s the difference between dating and being in a relationship, he says he not dating anyone else, dating site dumfries, indian dating marriage sites, definition of radiometric dating in science, what’s the best online dating service, dating websites glasgow, my daughter is dating a man older than me, wordpress themes for dating sites, que quiere decir wanna hook up, speed dating 18+, speed dating cleveland area, dating again over 40, supermarket speed dating, are haley and casey from american idol dating, dating profile headlines ideas, how to know when to start dating after divorce, can a stable isotope of carbon be used in carbon dating, bn dating login, south african sugar mama dating sites, racial preference gay dating, free dating sites liverpool uk, crazy dating advice, gay dating chat websites, speed dating in johnson city tn, dota 2 matchmaking status, dating uk polish, black and white dating sites uk, aus dating sites, austin and ally hook up fanfiction, free dating site in south african, tips for safely dating online, dating melba bone china, ex prostitute dating site, dating someone visually impaired, matchmaking with friends dota 2, russian and ukrainian dating sites, hook up again, lesbian dating apps malaysia, online dating phone number exchange, is there any real dating site, ny dating services, romantic dating simulation games, dating a minor laws in texas, online dating for cancer survivors, kerrville hookup, dating around in college, canada casual dating, 5 seconds of summer dating profiles, hook up saskatoon, legit hookup sites australia, interviews about online dating, perks of dating a drug dealer, best online dating site for hooking up, speed dating musulmans paris, no matchmaking heroic strike, lugansk ukraine dating agency, dating the introverted man, spencer dating caleb, umvc3 matchmaking, polish dating wroclaw, best gay dating sites usa, reviews for catholic dating sites, dating australian rock art, best dating site 30 somethings, pond of fish dating service, ang dating daan fundamental beliefs, just gloucester dating, stars dating history, usa dating websites free, online dating service wiki, smooch dating site app, speed dating northampton 2016, sleeping dogs dating cheating, dating princeton, pretty girl dating site, are rachel and santana dating, how do i find out if my husband has a dating profile, is there any 100 percent free dating sites, dating website barcelona spain, dating sites in texas, whatsapp dating site, sweet beginnings matchmaking, blendr dating reviews, top 5 interracial dating sites, 22 year old guy dating 25 year old woman, hook up cleveland, 7 stages of dating high school story, giving up dating for god, indian matchmaking melbourne, dating yakutsk, handicap dating gratis, 40 year old virgin speed dating gina, expiration dating and stability testing for human drug products, consequences of dating a younger man, waco online dating, good dating locations, forty days of dating love letters, online dating app reviews, banana matchmaking, make your own free dating site, different kinds dating sites, ncis fanfiction tony and ziva secretly dating, getting married after 2 weeks of dating, art dating site, nick amaro and amanda rollins dating, dating kosice, essay on online dating, more than friends not dating, 100 free dating sites with no credit card needed, alice springs dating site, perth dating sites free, jessica ost dating agency lirik, indian dating auto login, new nbc dating show, jasmine dating website, dating someone with family issues, speed dating halifax 2016, online dating safely, philadelphia dating site, snoop dogg son dating kendall jenner, christian dating sites australia, what percent of online dating works, modern dating a field guide ebook, free dating websites no charge, speed dating in gaithersburg md, america dating chat, bbc gay dating site, is a 19 year old dating a 25 year old weird, mall dare dating divas, dating apps in new zealand, flight crew dating site, interracial free dating uk, dating site istanbul, writing a online dating profile, indian dating websites south africa, cs go matchmaking ranks difference, dating site en france, good profile pictures online dating, london muslim dating website, league of legends ranked matchmaking, sign up for pof dating site, software match making, hook up your own car, dating work, learning disability dating websites, is matchmaking down csgo, cpa dating affiliate programs, free online dating and chatting site
П о д р а в л я е м ! З а б е р и т е В а ш п о д а р о ч н ы й б и л е т Г О С Л О Т О к ю б и л е й н о м у т и р а ж у п о д а н н о й с с ы л к е : http://www.tinyurl.com/Rexanafe SVWVE31621JUYEGRT